Heritage Farms, Inc. v. Markel Insurance Company

Appeal Number 2010AP000355

Supreme Court

SUMMARY
Short Caption
Status
Maintenance
 Ascending Date Order
 Descending Date Order
Heritage Farms, Inc. v. Markel Insurance Company
CL
Class
Court
Property Damage
Supreme Court
Disposition
County
Reversed and remanded
03-16-2012
Waushara

Circuit Court Case Numbers
Case Number
Circuit Court Judge
Responsible Circuit Court Judge
2004CV000131
Finn, John V.
Finn, John V.

Parties and Attorneys
Side
Party Name
Party Type(s)
Attorney(s)
Address
1
Heritage Farms, Inc.
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Dutcher, Clay Ryan
P. O. Box 807
Wautoma,  WI  54982-0807
1
Bunchkowski, Audrey
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Bunchkowski, Russell
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Dutcher, Ruth
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Dutcher, Howard
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Freitag, Sally
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Holzwart, Amy
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Holzwart, James
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Khin, Kathleen
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Zellmer, Glenwood
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Lloyd, Daryl
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Lloyd, Donald
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Maas, Judy
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Maas, Jeffrey
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Mueller, Carolyn
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Rucich, Lois
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Rucich, George
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Semrow, Donna
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Semrow, Harland
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Singer, Beverly
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Singer Trust, Norman A.
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Singer, Joan
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Singer, Gordon
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Singer Living Trust
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Stoellinger, Inga
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Stoellinger, Otto
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Swanton, Catherine
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Swanton Family Trust
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Toliver, Christine
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Toliver, Alan
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Zimmer, Krista
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Zimmer, Norman
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
Kaas, Sarah F.
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
1
Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest
Involuntary
Plaintiff
 
1
Auto-Owners Insurance Company
Involuntary
Plaintiff
 
1
Safeco Insurance Company of America
Involuntary
Plaintiff
Woody, Ryan L.
1111 E. Sumner St.
P.O. Box 270670
Hartford,  WI  53027-0670
1
Acuity, a mutual insurance company
Involuntary
Plaintiff
Thomsen, Mark
P.O. Box 1750
Brookfield,  WI  53008-1750
2
Markel Insurance Company
Defendant
Respondent
McCoy, John V.
Suite 125
N19W24200 Riverwood Drive
Waukesha,  WI  53188
Parish, Brian D.
N19W24200 Riverwood Dr., Ste. 125
Waukesha,  WI  53188
2
J.J.J. Recreation Corporation
Defendant
Respondent
McCoy, John V.
Suite 125
N19W24200 Riverwood Drive
Waukesha,  WI  53188
Parish, Brian D.
N19W24200 Riverwood Dr., Ste. 125
Waukesha,  WI  53188
2
American Family Mutual Insurance Company
Defendant
Respondent
Henkel, Mark S.
2900 Hoover Avenue, Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481-5607
Johnson, Eric R.
2900 Hoover Ave., Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481
2
Knaack, Jeffrey
Defendant
Respondent
Henkel, Mark S.
2900 Hoover Avenue, Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481-5607
Johnson, Eric R.
2900 Hoover Ave., Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481
1
Schwochert, Ted
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Beisenstein, Brian Patrick
2905 Universal Street
P. O. Box 2845
Oshkosh,  WI  54903-2845
1
Schwochert, Paul B.
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Beisenstein, Brian Patrick
2905 Universal Street
P. O. Box 2845
Oshkosh,  WI  54903-2845
1
Schwochert, Helen
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Beisenstein, Brian Patrick
2905 Universal Street
P. O. Box 2845
Oshkosh,  WI  54903-2845
1
Schroeder, Sue
Plaintiff
Appellant
Petitioner
Beisenstein, Brian Patrick
2905 Universal Street
P. O. Box 2845
Oshkosh,  WI  54903-2845
2
Markel Insurance Company
Defendant
Respondent
McCoy, John V.
Suite 125
N19W24200 Riverwood Drive
Waukesha,  WI  53188
Parish, Brian D.
N19W24200 Riverwood Dr., Ste. 125
Waukesha,  WI  53188
2
J.J.J. Recreation Corporation
Defendant
Respondent
McCoy, John V.
Suite 125
N19W24200 Riverwood Drive
Waukesha,  WI  53188
Parish, Brian D.
N19W24200 Riverwood Dr., Ste. 125
Waukesha,  WI  53188
2
American Family Mutual Insurance Company
Defendant
Respondent
Henkel, Mark S.
2900 Hoover Avenue, Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481-5607
Johnson, Eric R.
2900 Hoover Ave., Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481
2
Knaack, Jeffrey
Defendant
Respondent
Henkel, Mark S.
2900 Hoover Avenue, Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481-5607
Johnson, Eric R.
2900 Hoover Ave., Ste. A
Stevens Point,  WI  54481

Citation Information
Court
Volume
Publisher
Page
CA
331
Wis. 2d
64
CA
793
N.W.2d
896
SC
339
Wis. 2d
125
SC
810
N.W.2d
465

Public Domain Citation Information
Court
PDC
CA
2011 WI App 12
SC
2012 WI 26