Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. State of Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission

Appeal Number 2020AP002007

Supreme Court

SUMMARY
Short Caption
Status
Maintenance
 Ascending Date Order
 Descending Date Order
Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. State of Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission
CL
Class
Court
Administrative Agency Review
Supreme Court
Disposition
County
Affirmed
03-14-2024
Douglas

Circuit Court Case Numbers
Case Number
Circuit Court Judge
Responsible Circuit Court Judge
2019CV000324
Thimm, Kelly J.
Thimm, Kelly J.

Parties and Attorneys
Side
Party Name
Party Type(s)
Attorney(s)
Address
1
Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc.
Petitioner
Respondent
Petitioner
Torvinen, Kyle H.
823 Belknap St., Ste. 222
Superior,  WI  54880
Vitagliano, Daniel M.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Reaves, Nicholas R.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Rassbach, Eric C.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
1
Barron County Developmental Services, Inc.
Petitioner
Respondent
Petitioner
Torvinen, Kyle H.
823 Belknap St., Ste. 222
Superior,  WI  54880
Vitagliano, Daniel M.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Reaves, Nicholas R.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Rassbach, Eric C.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
1
Diversified Services, Inc.
Petitioner
Respondent
Petitioner
Torvinen, Kyle H.
823 Belknap St., Ste. 222
Superior,  WI  54880
Vitagliano, Daniel M.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Reaves, Nicholas R.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Rassbach, Eric C.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
1
Black River Industries, Inc.
Petitioner
Respondent
Petitioner
Torvinen, Kyle H.
823 Belknap St., Ste. 222
Superior,  WI  54880
Vitagliano, Daniel M.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Reaves, Nicholas R.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Rassbach, Eric C.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
1
Headwaters, Inc.
Petitioner
Respondent
Petitioner
Torvinen, Kyle H.
823 Belknap St., Ste. 222
Superior,  WI  54880
Vitagliano, Daniel M.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Reaves, Nicholas R.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
Rassbach, Eric C.
1919 Pennsylvania Ave. NW, Ste. 400
Washington,  DC  20006
2
State of Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission
Respondent
Co-Appellant
Shampo, Jeffrey J.
P.O. Box 8126
Madison,  WI  53708-8126
2
State of Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development
Respondent
Appellant
Galinat, Christine L.
P.O. Box 8942
Madison,  WI  53708-8942

Interested Parties
Name
Address
Title
Comment
Faircloth, Zachary
2001 Ross Avenue
Dallas,  TX  75201-2923
Amicus
Wisconsin Catholic Conference
Hubbard, Bradley G.
2001 Ross Avenue
Dallas,  TX  75201-2923
Amicus
Wisconsin Catholic Conference
Kiernan, Elizabeth A.
2001 Ross Avenue
Dallas,  TX  75201-2923
Amicus
Wisconsin Catholic Conference
Muehlhoff, Jason J.
2001 Ross Avenue
Dallas,  TX  75201-2923
Amicus
Wisconsin Catholic Conference
Earleywine, David
106 E. Doty, Ste. 300
Madison,  WI  53703
Amicus
Wisconsin Catholic Conference
Suhr, Daniel R.
747 N. LaSalle St. Ste. 210
Chicago,  IL  60654
Amicus
Gerbitz, Caleb Raymond
111 E. Kilbourn Ave., 19th Fl.
Milwaukee,  WI  53202
Amicus
Maranatha Baptist University, Maranatha Baptist Academy, Concordia University Wisconsin, the Wisconsin Family Counsel, and the Wisconsin Association of Christian Schools
Sosnoski, James M.
19th Floor
111 East Kilbourn Avenue
Milwaukee,  WI  53202
Amicus
Maranatha Baptist University, Maranatha Baptist Academy, Concordia University Wisconsin, the Wisconsin Family Counsel, and the Wisconsin Association of Christian Schools
Driscoll, Robert S.
P.O. Box 2965
Milwaukee,  WI  53202
Amicus
Judge, Stephen M.
100 E. Wayne Street, Suite 300
South Bend,  IN  46601
Amicus
Catholic Conferences of Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, and Minnesota
Kane, Tiernan
100 E. Wayne Street, Suite 300
South Bend,  IN  46601
Amicus
Catholic Conferences of Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, and Minnesota
Judge, Jonathan
233 South Wacker Dr., Ste. 7100
Chicago,  IL  60606
Amicus
Catholic Charities USA
Axelrod, Jon P.
2 E. Mifflin St., Ste. 600
Madison,  WI  53703-2865
Amicus
Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty
Webendorfer, J. Wesley
Two E. Mifflin St., Suite 600
Madison,  WI  53703-2865
Amicus
Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty
Slugh, Howard
2400 Virginia Ave N.W., Apt. C619
Washington,  DC  20037
Amicus
Jewish Coalition for Religious Liberty
Simon, David W.
Ste. 3600
777 E. Wisconsin Ave.
Milwaukee,  WI  53202-5367
Amicus
International Society for Krishna Consciousness and Sikh Coalition
Heinen, Gregory
777 E. Wisconsin Ave.
Milwaukee,  WI  53202-5306
Amicus
International Society for Krishna Consciousness and Sikh Coalition
Walsh, Ryan J.
Suite 621
10 East Doty Street
Madison,  WI  53703
Amicus
Wisconsin State Legislature
Tripoli, John David
224 S. Michigan Avenue, 11th Floor
Chicago,  IL  60604
Amicus
Feldhausen, Timothy John
318 South Washington Street
Green Bay,  WI  54301
Amicus
Professors Douglas Laycock & Thomas C. Berg
Woelfel, Tiffany E.
318 South Washington Street
Green Bay,  WI  54301
Amicus
Professors Douglas Laycock & Thomas C. Berg
Fernholz, Matthew M.
1601 East Racine Avenue, SUite 200
PO Box 558
Waukesha,  WI  53187
Amicus
Grover, Samuel
10 N. Henry St.
Madison,  WI  53703
Amicus
Freedom From Religion Foundation
Elliott, Patrick C.
P.O. Box 750
Madison,  WI  53701
Amicus
Freedom From Religion Foundation
Asirvatham, Rohit P.
680 Maine Avenue SW
Washington,  DC  20024
Amicus
Professors Douglas Laycock & Thomas C. Berg
Storslee, Mark S.
680 Maine Avenue SW
Washington,  DC  20024
Amicus
Professors Douglas Laycock & Thomas C. Berg
Harris, Sarah M.
680 Maine Avenue SW
Washington,  DC  20024
Amicus
Professors Douglas Laycock & Thomas C. Berg
Schaerr, Gene C.
1717 K Street, Ste. 900
Washington,  DC  20006
Amicus
Minnesota-Wisconsin Baptist Convention, Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod, National Association of Evangelicals...
Phillips, James C.
1717 K Street NW, Ste. 900
Washington,  DC  20006
Amicus
Minnesota-Wisconsin Baptist Convention, Lutheran Church - Missouri Synod, National Association of Evangelicals...
Swank, Levi
1900 N Street, N.W.
Washington,  DC  20036
Amicus
International Society for Krishna Consciousness and Sikh Coalition
Hayes, Benjamin
1900 N Street N.W.
Washington,  DC  20036
Amicus
International Society for Krishna Consciousness and Sikh Coalition
Ljekperic, Dina
620 Eighth Ave.
New York,  NY  10018-1618
Amicus
International Society for Krishna Consciousness and Sikh Coalition

Citation Information
Court
Volume
Publisher
Page
CA
406
Wis. 2d
586
CA
987
N.W.2d
778

Public Domain Citation Information
Court
PDC
CA
2023 WI App 12
CA
2023 WI App 2
SC
2024 WI 13