Voters with Facts v. City of Eau Claire
Appeal Number 2015AP001858
Supreme Court
SUMMARY
|
Short Caption
|
Status
|
Maintenance
|
|
||
|
Voters with Facts v. City of Eau Claire
|
CL
|
||||
|
Class
|
Court
|
||||
|
Declaratory Judgment
|
Supreme Court
|
||||
|
Disposition
|
County
|
||||
|
Affirmed
06-06-2018 |
Eau Claire
|
||||
|
Circuit Court Case Numbers
|
|
Case Number
|
Circuit Court Judge
|
Responsible Circuit Court Judge
|
|
2015CV000175
|
Lenz, Paul J.
|
Lenz, Paul J.
|
|
Parties and Attorneys
|
|
Side
|
Party Name
|
Party Type(s)
|
Attorney(s)
|
Address
|
|
1
|
Voters with Facts
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Pure Savage Enterprises, LLC
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Wisconsin Three, LLC
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
215 Farwell LLC
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Dewloc, LLC
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Anderson, Leah
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Bartl, J. Peter
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Burton, Cynthia
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Charlson, Corinne
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Cohen, Maryjo
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Cruz, Jo Ann Hoeppner
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Mantik, Rachel
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Olson, Judy
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Riley, Janeway
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Webster, Christine
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Westermann, Dorothy
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Wnukowski, Janice
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Wood, David
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
1
|
Zank, Paul
|
Plaintiff
Appellant Petitioner |
Esenberg, Richard M.
|
330 East Kilbourn Avenue, Suite 725
Milwaukee, WI 53202-3141 |
|
McGrath, Brian W.
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
Kamenick, Thomas Claire
|
Bloodgood House
1139 E. Knapp St. Milwaukee, WI 53202-2828 |
|||
|
2
|
City of Eau Claire
|
Defendant
Respondent |
Nick, Stephen C.
|
203 S. Farwell St.
Eau Claire, WI 54701 |
|
Bitar, Remzy D.
|
730 N. Grand Ave.
Waukesha, WI 53186 |
|||
|
Hoffer, Douglas James
|
City Hall
203 S. Farwell St., 3rd Floor Eau Claire, WI 54701 |
|||
|
2
|
City of Eau Claire Joint Review Board
|
Defendant
Respondent |
Nick, Stephen C.
|
203 S. Farwell St.
Eau Claire, WI 54701 |
|
Bitar, Remzy D.
|
730 N. Grand Ave.
Waukesha, WI 53186 |
|||
|
Hoffer, Douglas James
|
City Hall
203 S. Farwell St., 3rd Floor Eau Claire, WI 54701 |
|||
|
Interested Parties
|
|
Name
|
Address
|
Title
|
Comment
|
|
Steffes, Ryan
|
P.O. Box 1030
Eau Claire, WI 54702-1030 |
Amicus
|
counsel for Eau Claire Area Chamber of Commerce, Inc.
|
|
Larson, Thomas D.
|
4801 Forest Run Rd., Ste. 201
Madison, WI 53704-7337 |
Amicus
|
counsel for Wisconsin REALTORS Association, NAIOP-WI & Wisconsin Economic Development Association
|
|
Langley, Grant F.
|
841 North Broadway, Room 716
Milwaukee, WI 53202 |
Amicus
|
counsel for City of Milwaukee
|
|
Schanning, Mary L.
|
841 North Broadway, Room 716
Milwaukee, WI 53202 |
Amicus
|
counsel for City of Milwaukee
|
|
Hagopian, Gregg
|
841 North Broadway, Room 716
Milwaukee, WI 53202 |
Amicus
|
counsel for City of Milwaukee
|
|
Silverman, Claire M.
|
131 W Wilson St Suite 505
Madison, WI 53703 |
Amicus
|
counsel for League of Wisconsin Municipalities
|
|
May, Michael P.
|
Room 401
210 Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd. Madison, WI 53703-3345 |
Amicus
|
|
|
Manthe, Richard
|
W7686 County Road MMM
Shawano, WI 54166-6086 |
Amicus
|
counsel for Wisconsin Towns Association
|
|
Tseytlin, Misha
|
P.O. Box 7857
Madison, WI 53707-7857 |
Amicus
|
counsel for State of Wisconsin
|
|
LeRoy, Kevin M.
|
P.O. Box 7857
Madison, WI 53707-7857 |
Amicus
|
counsel for State of Wisconsin
|
|
Citation Information
|
|
Court
|
Volume
|
Publisher
|
Page
|
|
CA
|
376
|
Wis. 2d
|
479
|
|
CA
|
899
|
N.W.2d
|
706
|
|
SC
|
382
|
Wis. 2d
|
1
|
|
SC
|
913
|
N.W.2d
|
131
|
|
Public Domain Citation Information
|
|
Court
|
PDC
|
|
CA
|
2017 WI App 35
|
|
SC
|
2018 WI 63
|
|
|